India needs a Minister For Internet

The most common ‘grouse’ you hear from VCs or internet entrepreneurs is – when will the govt push for internet penetration?

The govt of India did the correct thing by having a portfolio for IT and Telecom. While I think IT and Telecom are completely different and they ought to have separate ministries it is better than not having any thing at all. But then I seem to be recommending to increase the size of the already bloated cabinet size! Me bad!

Today I was with a private Telco which has done a great job in providing broadband in India. Few things I learnt from him,

  • WiMAX has not succeeded in a large scale anywhere in the world. India needs to wait for a long time to see WiMAX in a serious way
  • Telcos prefer to go after corporate accounts instead of home broadband connectivity (since ROI is less from home users)
  • To lay 1 km of cable (last mile) telcos spend Rs 1 crore (Rs 10 lakh on material, Rs 90 lakh for various govt agencies). What is the telco’s incentive to increase broadband connectivity to homes?
  • South Korean govt has laid cables all over the country and leases out the last mile connection to any ISP that is interested. In India BSNL will never agree to lease out their last mile connectivity.
Broadband cables of telcos in Bengaluru

Broadband cables of telcos in Bengaluru

There is too much red tape from State governments when it comes to providing last time connectivity (they don’t give you permission to dig roads very easily).

For the next 5 years the govt should have a ‘Minister For Internet’ or at least a ‘Minister of State – Internet’.

How can a Minister of Internet help?

Since this ministry’s job will be only to increase the connectivity in India, I am sure the connections will increase dramatically. By having a lot more internet users,

  • Existing internet companies will do better because revenue will increase, more taxes for the govt and possibly more jobs will be created
  • Many Indians desire to be successful entrepreneurs. Once they see this surging internet user base a lot more will start their own internet ventures. This is good for the country.
  • With revenues increasing entrepreneurs will come up with new ideas. VCs will start believing a lot more about the internet space in India. We will see more investments happening. Good for the entire eco-system.
  • A huge ‘new’ user base from Tier-II cities will have access to content over the net. Students can be a lot more smarter by having access to latest information. Why should Tier-II students be denied access to better content that could help them in their careers?

We need someone to head this effort who actually appreciates the internet space. We don’t need a minister who will insist on having his or her statue being installed on each junction box! That would be a nightmare.

We don’t want the govt to help us with the internet business directly. Help us by just increasing the penetration, the rest, please leave it to the internet companies, they will figure it out.

If the govt does appoint one, we dotcom geeks can finally say “Yes Minister!


  1. Its high time Union government create a berth for internet minister. The incumbent minister must log once in a day.

  2. I would nominate Shashi Tharoor as Minsiter for the Internet…he seems to be one of the few tech savvy ministers in the present Cabinet. ^ million broadband users in a country this size is a bloody joke


  1. […] One of the reasons for not having internet service in Tier-1 cities is because of the classic last mile problem. Govts don’t give permission to dig the roads, telcos find it expensive to lay cables to each house. […]

  2. […] had written few months back that unless we have a dedicated Minister for Internet one cannot expect to see exponential growth in the Internet user […]

  3. […] if we had a dedicated Internet Minister – penetration would have been far higher. Filed Under: internet Tagged With: internet […]

  4. […] back in 2009 I had written India needs a Minister for Internet, now we have a Prime Minister who believes in the internet, especially in social media. We do hope […]

  5. […] India needs a Minister For Internet […]

  6. […] India should learn from South Korea – it should lay the cables all around the city and rent out the infrastructure to telcos. Wish India had a Minister for Internet. […]

  7. […] In India if internet usage needs a huge push (which it does), we need an Minister for Internet. […]

  8. […] One of the reasons for not having internet service in Tier-1 cities is because of the classic last mile problem. Govts don’t give permission to dig the roads, telcos find it expensive to lay cables to each house. […]

  9. […] needs an Internet Minister in the cabinet. Basic qualification – he/she needs to be using the […]

Leave a Reply